Standard Variant Picker vs. Product Variations Block

Wonder Theme offers two distinct ways to handle product variations on your Shopify store: the Standard Variant Picker (Shopify’s native variant solution) and the Product Variations Block (a custom Wonder Theme feature). This guide compares the two approaches side-by-side, so you can decide which is best for your needs.

Standard Variant Picker (Shopify Native Variants)

The Standard Variant Picker is Shopify’s built-in solution for product options. It allows customers to select variants (like color or size) from a single product’s page. This method uses Shopify’s native variant system with default swatches or dropdowns for each option, combining all choices within one product listing. It’s straightforward and ideal for simpler product setups.

Native Shopify solution: Uses the default variant functionality provided by Shopify, with no extra apps or code needed.
All options in one product: Combines all product options (e.g. color, size, style) as variants of a single product in your catalog. Customers see one product page and choose options there.
Uses native swatches & selectors: Supports Shopify’s built-in swatches, buttons, or dropdown menus for variant selection. You can enable color swatches or variant images through Shopify’s standard settings.
No metafields required: Setup is done in the Shopify admin by adding variants to a product. There’s no need for custom metafields or metaobjects for variant data.
Best for simple setups: Suitable when your variations are straightforward (just different colors, sizes, etc.) and don’t require unique content per variant. All variants share the same product description and page, which keeps things simple.

Product Variations Block (Wonder Theme Feature)

The Product Variations Block is a special feature of the Wonder Theme that lets you display separate products as selectable “variants” on a single page. In other words, it groups standalone products and presents them as variant options using swatches or buttons. This effectively flattens your catalog structure by showing related products in one place, while still keeping each as its own product in the backend. This approach offers greater flexibility for merchandising complex product lines.

Custom Wonder Theme feature: Provided by the theme (not a default Shopify function). It adds a block on the product page to showcase other products as options.
Combines separate products into one view: Instead of one product with many variants, you link multiple individual products together. Shoppers see one product detail page with swatches for each related product (e.g. different styles or flavors), and selecting a swatch switches the page to that product’s info.
Requires metafields/metaobjects: Setting this up involves creating custom metafields (and possibly metaobject definitions) in Shopify. For example, you might use a product metafield (list of products) to list all related product handles, and a color metaobject for swatch colors. Some technical knowledge of Shopify’s metafields is needed to configure this block properly.
Rich customization per variation: Because each “variation” is actually its own product, you can tailor content to each one. Each variation can have its own images, description, media, and even a unique URL or SEO settings. This is more flexible than standard variants, which all share most content. (This mirrors Shopify’s Combined Listings feature available to Plus merchants, where each product variation can have a unique image gallery and description)‍
Ideal for complex products: Great for scenarios where variations differ significantly or need separate content – for example, products that come in various models or editions, each with distinct images or detailed info. It allows a unified shopping experience (one page for all variations) without sacrificing the ability to manage each variant as a separate product in your admin.

Aspect	Standard Variant Picker (Shopify Native)	Product Variations Block (Wonder Theme)
Underlying Structure	All variants are within one product (single product with multiple variant options in Shopify).	Variations are separate products linked together and displayed as options on one page.
Variant Display	Uses Shopify’s built-in selectors: customers choose options via dropdowns, buttons, or swatches for color, size, etc.	Displays swatches or buttons for each linked product, appearing as variant choices on the product page.
Setup Complexity	Easy setup: Create variants in the Shopify admin (no special configuration needed). No metafields or code required.	Advanced setup: Requires configuring metafields/metaobjects to link products and define option values (e.g. color swatch images). Involves more initial work and Shopify knowledge.
Catalog Organization	Simple catalog: One product handle covers all variants. Your storefront and collections show one product listing.	Flattened catalog: Multiple products (with separate handles/URLs) are merged into one view for customers. Collections can still list each item individually if desired.
Content per Variation	Shared content: Variants share the same product page content (description, URL) except for variant-specific images or SKU. Limited ability to vary info like descriptions per variant.	Unique content: Each “variation” has its own product page behind the scenes, allowing distinct images, descriptions, titles, and even unique URLs or rich media for each variant option. This enables more tailored content (even A+ style sections) per variation.
Use Case Suitability	Best for basic variations (e.g. sizes or colors) where differences are minor and a unified description fits all. Ideal for small catalogs or products that don’t need separate pages for each variant.	Best for complex variations or broad product ranges – for instance, when each variant needs its own storytelling, separate inventory tracking, or marketing. Useful to showcase related but distinct products (styles, flavors, models) in one place.
Shopify Plan Dependency	Available on all Shopify plans (this is core Shopify functionality).	Available to any store using Wonder Theme. (Natively, combining products into one listing is a Shopify Plus-only feature via the Combined Listings app, but this theme block provides a workaround for non-Plus stores.)

When to Use Each Approach

Use the Standard Variant Picker if: you have a straightforward product setup with simple options. For example, if you sell T-shirts in different sizes or colors that don’t need separate descriptions or pages, the native variant picker keeps things simple. It’s easy to manage and requires no extra configuration – all variants live in one product, which is efficient for inventory and basic variant image swaps.

Use the Product Variations Block if: your product variations are essentially separate products or you want to showcase highly differentiated variants together. This approach is recommended when each variant might warrant its own imagery, detailed description, or unique selling points (e.g. different designs in a collection, or a product available in distinct formats). It’s especially helpful for larger or Plus-sized catalogs where merchandising related products as one improves the shopping experience. Keep in mind you’ll need to set up metafields and possibly maintain multiple products in admin, but the payoff is a richer, combined product presentation for your customers.

Conclusion

Both options can enhance your product pages in Wonder Theme – the choice comes down to your store’s complexity and needs. If you value simplicity and out-of-the-box ease, the Standard Variant Picker is the way to go. If you need greater flexibility and the ability to treat each variation as its own product while still giving shoppers a one-page selection experience, the Product Variations Block is a powerful solution. By understanding the differences outlined above, you can confidently choose the approach that provides the best shopping experience for your customers and the easiest management for you.

Back